Shipping and returns used to be an afterthought. Today they are conversion levers, loyalty engines, and margin landmines. After reviewing 150 DTC policies across apparel, beauty, home, and electronics, we distilled what leaders consistently do, why it moves conversion and LTV, and how you can implement the same playbook without eroding profit.

What top brands offer on shipping

Free shipping remains a powerful signal of value and trust. Among North America’s largest online retailers, 71.2 percent offered some form of free shipping in 2024 according to Digital Commerce 360’s fulfillment analysis, and 73.9 percent of shoppers rated free shipping the most important fulfillment factor when choosing a retailer. The report further shows speed of delivery ranked second, underscoring that cost and speed shape buyer choice (Digital Commerce 360).

Hidden fees are conversion killers. Reasons for abandonment data from the Baymard Institute shows that 39 percent of shoppers quit due to extra costs like shipping, taxes, and fees. The same research notes that 15 percent abandon because the returns policy is not satisfactory, and 21 percent leave because delivery is too slow (Baymard). Translation: if you do not show transparent shipping costs early, and if your returns promise feels risky, you will bleed conversion long before a user reaches the payment step.

For threshold strategy, best practice is to set a free shipping minimum slightly above current AOV so customers add one more item. Shopify recommends setting a threshold above average order value to reliably increase AOV while protecting margins, and provides examples of how to model this in practice (Shopify’s guide). Combine that with strong pre-checkout disclosure of shipping costs, accurate delivery estimates, and a clear cut-off for expedited options.

What top brands offer on returns

Returns policy clarity drives both first purchase confidence and repeat purchase behavior. In a joint report, the National Retail Federation and Happy Returns found that 76 percent of consumers consider free returns a key factor in where they shop, while 67 percent say a negative return experience would discourage them from shopping with a retailer again (NRF). The same research highlights rising investments in box-free and label-free returns because 84 percent of consumers are more likely to shop with retailers that offer them.

Top DTC brands increasingly steer customers toward exchanges or store credit to retain revenue. Narvar’s State of Returns report notes that an optimized returns flow can convert up to 60 percent of returns into exchanges or store credit, which directly protects revenue and improves lifetime value (Narvar via PR Newswire). Loop Returns analyzed 22 million returns across more than 4,000 Shopify merchants and reports that features like Shop Now product exchanges reduce refund revenue and drive incremental upsell per return, while store credit with bonus credit is widely used to retain revenue that would otherwise be refunded (Loop Winter 2024 Benchmark).

Meanwhile, the economics are forcing nuance. In a September 2024 survey, 60 percent of US retail professionals said charging customers for returns increased adoption of free return methods like in-person drop off, and 54 percent said it reduced return rates. The data also reiterates that consumers still value free returns, so smart policy design nudges behavior without detonating conversion (EMARKETER summarizing NRF/Happy Returns). Leading brands reconcile these pressures by making exchanges free, offering bonus credit for store credit, and applying modest fees to refund-to-original-payment when items are not defective.

The conversion and LTV math behind shipping and returns

Extra costs are still the number one reason for abandonment, so shipping strategy is a checkout optimization lever as much as a logistics decision. Baymard’s research shows the average abandonment rate hovers around 70 percent, with solvable checkout issues representing a large share of recoverable revenue. Their data indicates a better checkout design can unlock a double digit conversion rate increase, and shipping cost clarity plus acceptable return promises sit at the center of those gains (Baymard).

Returns influence lifetime value beyond the immediate transaction. The NRF estimates total retail returns reached 890 billion dollars in 2024, with 16.9 percent of annual sales returned. That size justifies investing in revenue retention strategies like exchanges and store credit, which keep customers active while protecting margin (NRF). Narvar’s findings connect a smoother returns journey with higher repeat purchase likelihood, and Loop’s benchmarks show merchants who make instant or advanced exchanges easy reduce refunds and increase upsell, with reported uplifts in repeat purchase and monthly spend for exchange-first experiences in high-return verticals (Narvar via PR Newswire; Loop Benchmark).

How to copy the playbook

• Set an intentional threshold. Model a free shipping minimum 20 to 30 percent above current AOV to lift basket size without over-subsidizing small orders, following guidance from Shopify’s free shipping playbook. If you want a deeper pricing toolkit, use our AOV and margin guide at StoreAcquire and bundling frameworks for LTV at this post.

• Make exchanges the hero. Offer free exchanges and add bonus credit for store credit to shift demand away from refunds. The Loop benchmark shows exchanges and Shop Now flows reduce refund revenue and capture upsell per return.

• Be explicit on PDP, cart, and checkout. Baymard’s data makes clear that lack of cost visibility and weak return promises harm conversion. Adopt the 3-click rule for policy discovery, and test above-the-fold shipping and returns callouts with estimated delivery windows. Our 27 checkout tests prioritize these friction reducers (StoreAcquire checkout guide).

• Offer box-free, label-free drop offs and instant credit when feasible. Consumer preference for these options is strong, which NRF and Happy Returns highlight, and adoption improves conversion on first purchase (NRF).

• Use returns data to prevent returns. Capture structured return reasons and feed them into PDP copy, size guides, and pre-purchase quizzes. Our zero-party data playbook shows how to use fit and needs quizzes to improve first-time right purchases and segment messaging (quiz playbook; zero-party for email and SMS).

A 30-day implementation checklist for Shopify brands

• Week 1: Audit shipping and returns copy across PDP, cart, and checkout. Add upfront cost transparency and delivery estimates. Use our checkout guide for test ideas.

• Week 2: Set a threshold 20 to 30 percent above AOV. Pair it with entry-level bundles that naturally meet the threshold using these bundling frameworks.

• Week 3: Launch free exchanges, add bonus credit for store credit, and set a modest fee for refund-to-original payment. Implement box-free drop off where possible, guided by NRF insights.

• Week 4: Instrument return reasons, build a size or fit quiz, and feed insights into PDP content. For growth ops and attribution guardrails, use our attribution guide to measure downstream LTV of exchange-first cohorts.

If you are building your stack, Shopify’s ecosystem makes this fast to execute, from native shipping rules to returns apps and quizzes. You can get started with Shopify and layer in returns optimization using the tools referenced above.

StoreAcquire is a free weekly newsletter for founders and operators who want practical wins and timely market intelligence. Join 15,000 plus entrepreneurs at StoreAcquire or learn more about us. You can browse our latest case studies and playbooks anytime in the posts archive.