The most resilient ecommerce brands are not choosing between Amazon and direct-to-consumer. They are mastering both. Amazon controls a massive share of digital shopping intent and logistics while DTC drives brand equity, margin control, and first-party data. The trick is designing a hybrid strategy that grows total brand revenue without the margin leaks, channel conflict, or operational chaos that sink many well-intentioned expansions.

According to eMarketer’s February 2024 forecast, Amazon was set to capture 40.4 percent of US retail ecommerce sales in 2024, or about 491.65 billion dollars, which is too much shopping activity to ignore if you sell physical goods. The firm’s analysis notes that Amazon remains the most powerful force in retail media as well, with retail media ad revenues forecast to reach 69.3 billion dollars in 2025, representing roughly 39.8 percent of the category. Those two realities fuse into one strategic imperative: your hybrid plan must integrate sales, ads, and ops across channels with clear guardrails and a clear P&L.

Why hybrid now: demand, data, and defensibility

Brands that rely on a single channel face rising costs and volatility. Meta and Google ad markets continue to fluctuate, and shoppers compare prices across marketplaces before purchasing. Social commerce is also growing quickly. As eMarketer’s outlook on social commerce explains, US sales were expected to reach 71.62 billion dollars in 2024, with TikTok Shop a key growth driver. That means Amazon is not the only marketplace competing for your customer’s wallet.

The Amazon stack can now power both marketplace growth and your DTC conversion. Amazon’s Buy with Prime has shown an average 25 percent lift in shopper conversion on participating merchant sites, according to Amazon’s own program results. With Shopify and Amazon announcing a native Buy with Prime app integration in 2023, it became far easier to combine Prime trust and logistics with your brand-owned checkout. For DTC foundations, Shopify’s official pricing shows card processing fees typically starting at 2.9 percent plus 30 cents per transaction on the Basic plan, making the economics transparent enough to model alongside Amazon fees.

Retail media gravity is another reason to embrace hybrid. The IAB and PwC’s 2024 Internet Advertising Revenue Report found that retail media network ad revenues rose 23 percent year over year to 53.7 billion dollars in 2024. As Amazon’s advertising revenue continues to rise, brands that invest in measurement and clean-room analysis can unlock incremental reach, not mere cannibalization.

Where channel conflict really comes from on Amazon

Most conflict comes down to price, availability, and inconsistent packaging.

• Amazon’s Marketplace Fair Pricing Policy states that Amazon monitors prices and compares them to other available prices for customers. If Amazon detects price disparity or anti-competitive pricing, it can suppress the Featured Offer or remove the listing.

• The concept formerly known as the Buy Box, now the Featured Offer, is governed by factors like price, delivery speed, and customer experience. Seller Central documentation explains what the Featured Offer is and how offers qualify, which effectively enforces price competitiveness.

• Amazon does not enforce MAP policies. As one seller resource explains, sellers often assume Amazon will enforce minimum advertised price policies, but Amazon’s platform does not police MAP agreements. Instead, Amazon looks at whether the marketplace price is competitive and fair for customers.

Brands sometimes think they can set a DTC price, match it on Amazon, then walk away. The reality is that any below-MAP reseller, short-term markdown, or gifting bundle can trigger algorithmic price comparisons that reduce your Featured Offer eligibility or suppress your listing entirely. Furthermore, while Amazon ended its explicit third-party price parity policy in the US years ago, regulatory scrutiny continues. The Washington Post’s coverage of the FTC’s 2023 antitrust lawsuit alleges that Amazon used anti-discounting tactics and high fees to thwart price competition, which signals how sensitive the platform is about price signals.

Pricing governance that prevents conflict and protects margin

Strong governance is a living document and an operational habit. Brands that keep margin and channels aligned typically do all of the following.

• Define SKU families to keep like-for-like pricing comparable only where intended. If your DTC site offers a 2-pack and Amazon has a 3-pack with a channel-exclusive insert, direct price comparison becomes less volatile while remaining fair.

• Set a channel floor and discount cadence. Your governance should describe which channels can discount, by how much, and how often. Your DTC can run gated offers to subscribers without creating public price pressure. Your Amazon assortment can lean into value-driven bundles that justify the price per unit.

• Use a unilateral pricing policy if your legal counsel approves. A UPP lets a brand publish a minimum resale price as a unilateral policy without asking resellers to agree. Retail operations resources explain how UPPs differ from MAP and how they can be administratively simpler to enforce with authorized dealers. This is not legal advice. Work with counsel on language and enforcement.

• Monitor and remediate. Create a cadence to audit your top 80 percent of revenue SKUs weekly for price violations, rogue listings, and suppressed Featured Offer flags. Build playbooks for authorized reseller communication and for Amazon ticketing when listings need correction.

If you are rethinking your price architecture or looking to raise average order value systematically, StoreAcquire’s detailed pricing frameworks can help. This includes a practical model for ecommerce pricing strategy to lift AOV and protect margin and a companion on bundling frameworks that increase AOV and LTV. Both are designed for founders and operators who want governance that sticks.

P&L modeling: 1P, 3P, and DTC as distinct unit economics

You do not need perfect data to make better decisions. You need a consistent P&L template that forces apples-to-apples comparisons across channels.

Start with three waterfalls and one scenario sheet.

1. Amazon 3P Seller model

• Top line: Average Selling Price, less promotions and returns.

• Amazon fees: Referral fees vary by category and typically sit around 8 to 15 percent, as outlined in Seller Central’s referral fee tables.

• Fulfillment: FBA inbound placement service fees and fulfillment fees, plus storage. Amazon introduced a low-inventory-level fee in 2024 that applies when historical days of supply fall below thresholds. Factor this in as inventory insurance.

• Retail media: TACOS at the item level. If you do not know item TACOS, allocate at portfolio level and stress test at 5, 10, and 15 percent.

• Net contribution: Subtract cost of goods sold and account for overhead allocation.

2. Amazon 1P Vendor model

• Top line: Net POs at negotiated wholesale price.

• Trade terms: Co-op, damage allowances, and chargebacks. Many vendors shift to 3P to regain pricing control and reduce chargebacks. Marketplace Pulse noted that third-party seller share reached an all-time high in Q4 2024, which reflects Amazon’s strategic tilt toward marketplace dynamics.

• Ads: Vendor retail media and onsite promotions.

• Net contribution: Factor in the lower price point but lower variable fees.

3. DTC model

• Top line: Average order value, less discounts and returns.

• Payments: Shopify Payments on the Basic plan is typically 2.9 percent plus 30 cents per transaction, per Shopify’s pricing page.

• Fulfillment and shipping: Pick-pack fees and carrier rates. If using Amazon Multi-Channel Fulfillment, Amazon states you can select blank box shipping for unbranded packaging on eligible orders, which helps preserve the DTC brand feel.

• CAC: Paid media blended CPA, plus email and SMS costs amortized per order. If you use quizzes and preference centers to collect zero-party data, acquisition compounds over time. StoreAcquire’s zero-party data playbook outlines how to make that happen.

4. Scenario sheet

• Create a simple simulator to test 10 percent price moves, TACOS from 5 to 15 percent, and CAC swings of plus or minus 20 percent. Use contribution per order and contribution per unit as your decision anchor. If your Amazon 3P TACOS creeps past your DTC CAC at equivalent contribution, revisit your channel mix.

The goal is not to pick winners but to define thresholds. For instance, set a rule: if TACOS is greater than X and inventory turns fall below Y, shift the SKU to bundle-only on Amazon and reallocate spend to DTC prospecting. If CAC climbs above Z, lean into Amazon where intent is stronger and buy-side efficiency is higher.

If you want a hands-on example of how operators tune a P&L as they scale, StoreAcquire’s DTC growth case study from 50k to 500k MRR shows the exact levers that stabilize cash and expand margin.

Operating model: inventory, logistics, and the Featured Offer

Inventory is where hybrid strategies live or die. McKinsey’s research on omnichannel operations argues for integrated one-inventory concepts so you can dynamically position stock for demand while reducing working capital, but there are marketplace-specific constraints to respect. Amazon’s low-inventory-level fee makes it costly to starve FBA stock, and Featured Offer eligibility often requires both competitive price and reliable availability.

Practical steps that keep operations stable:

• Separate safety stock pools for Amazon and DTC when your FBA velocity is unpredictable. Once your forecast error tightens, move toward an integrated pool to lower holding costs.

• Use Amazon Multi-Channel Fulfillment for DTC backstops sparingly and with unbranded packaging when needed, as Amazon’s MCF documentation explains. Keep your DTC experience consistent and your packaging differentiated.

• Align prep and packaging by channel. Insert cards with warranties and product education in DTC orders. Use channel-agnostic inserts on Amazon to avoid seller policy violations.

To improve DTC conversion while keeping ops simple, consider Buy with Prime on select product pages. Amazon says average conversion lift is 25 percent for participating merchants, and the Shopify integration makes implementation fast. If you do not have a DTC storefront yet or are migrating, building on Shopify offers the fastest path to testing hybrid tactics like channel-specific bundles, customized checkout flows, and first-party data capture.

Measurement and incrementality: know what Amazon adds

Attribution will remain messy as platforms shift policies. Adweek reported in October 2025 that Google’s Privacy Sandbox program was effectively shelved, continuing the long saga of third-party cookie uncertainty. Either way, the direction is clear. To prove Amazon incrementality without relying on last-click, combine first-party data with clean-room analysis and media mix modeling.

• Amazon Marketing Cloud is Amazon’s privacy-safe clean room that lets advertisers query event-level signals to analyze path-to-purchase, frequency, and audience overlap. Amazon’s AMC overview details how brands can structure custom SQL queries and even bring their own datasets via AWS Clean Rooms to measure incrementality beyond ad console reports.

• For your DTC and cross-channel media, adopt a triad: GA4 for directional site analytics, channel lift experiments where possible, and periodic MMM to calibrate budget allocation. StoreAcquire’s guide to attribution in 2025 with GA4, MMM, and first-party data shows how founders can right-size measurement without enterprise overhead.

When you triangulate AMC, MMM, and your unit economics sheets, you can answer a simple but vital question: does Amazon advertising create net new customers or just re-route existing demand? If the answer drifts toward the latter, rotate your Amazon media toward prospecting formats and non-branded keywords while reinforcing DTC with email, SMS, and on-site personalization.

A practical rollout plan that avoids conflict and chaos

You can stand up a hybrid program in 90 days without breaking your margin structure. Here is a focused sequence.

1. Assortment and packaging design. Select 5 to 10 SKUs to start. Create bundle or pack-size differentiation for Amazon to reduce direct price comparisons while keeping value consistent.

2. Pricing governance. Publish your channel price floors, promo cadences, and authorized reseller rules. If appropriate, formalize a unilateral pricing policy with counsel.

3. Amazon setup. Launch or clean up your catalog, win the Featured Offer with competitive price and inventory, and configure FBA. Use Seller Central’s pricing tools to monitor competitive moves and Fair Pricing Policy flags.

4. DTC optimization. Ship on Shopify for speed. Implement guardrail tests from StoreAcquire’s checkout optimization list. Use quizzes to collect zero-party data from day one with the segmentation and LTV playbook.

5. Retail media and measurement. Stand up Amazon Ads with a branded defense, non-branded exploration, and retargeting. Activate Amazon Marketing Cloud to understand pathing. Run MMM quarterly to inform channel budgets.

6. Social marketplaces. Spin up TikTok Shop pilots with StoreAcquire’s GTM plan or the tactical 30-day launch plan to diversify marketplace exposure without increasing price conflict.

7. Review cadence. Hold a weekly pricing and inventory standup. Adjust TACOS and CAC targets based on contribution margin thresholds. Update governance as you learn.

Decisions get easier when you have a shared language for price, inventory, and incrementality. A hybrid program built on packaging differentiation, explicit price guardrails, and channel-by-channel P&L discipline can raise AOV, protect margin, and make your brand resilient across cycles. If the macro turns choppy, StoreAcquire’s ecommerce recession playbook details cash, forecasting, and pricing tactics that keep you playing offense.

StoreAcquire exists to help founders move faster on exactly these decisions. The free weekly newsletter distills operator-grade playbooks on pricing, checkout, and growth so you can ship improvements without guesswork. Join the community at StoreAcquire.com, explore the latest posts and case studies, or learn more about the mission. When you are ready to put these ideas to work, subscribing is free and takes seconds.